August 3, 2017Hon. Malcolm Turnbull MPPrime MinisterParliament HouseCANBERRA ACT 2600
Re: Encryption and Human Rights
Dear Prime Minister Turnbull,
We write to urge you to support the use of strong encryption as essential to security and human rights in the digital age. We call on you to refrain from forcing technology companies to weaken the security of their products or banning the use of end-to-end encryption.
In a July 14 press conference on national security and encryption, you discussed challenges that Australian law enforcement and intelligence agencies faced in accessing encrypted data or communications, even with a lawful court order. You announced your intention to introduce legislation that will in particular impose an obligation upon device manufacturers and upon service providers to provide appropriate assistance to intelligence and law enforcement on a warranted basis, to access data in unencrypted form. While the conference released few details, you stated that the legislation would be modelled on the United Kingdoms Investigatory Powers Act and that you will seek a coordinated approach with international partners, including the Five Eyes intelligence alliance.
Governments have a human rights obligation to investigate and prosecute crime and thwart terrorist attacks. However, any policy response should not do more harm than good, while also be effective at achieving its aim. Forcing companies to weaken encryption or effectively forbidding the use of end-to-end encryption fails on both counts, and would undermine human rights worldwide.
Strong encryption is the cornerstone of cybersecurity in the digital age. Todays cybercriminals are increasingly sophisticated, targeting Internet companies, credit card and identity data, critical infrastructure, and even nation-state intelligence agencies. Strong encryption built into private sector technology protects the dataand the human rights and securityof billions of Internet users worldwide against these growing security threats. You yourself have acknowledged that you use encrypted applications like Wickr and WhatsApp because traditional communication methods are not secure.
Weakening encryption for any purpose effectively weakens it for every purpose, including malicious hacking, financial fraud, and for other illicit purposes. And unfortunately, weak or partial encryption provides not just weak or partial protection, but no protection at all against sophisticated repressive regimes and capable criminals. Some companies that manufacture encrypted apps or devices do not have the ability to disclose conversations or data to law enforcement because that information is encrypted end-to-end and companies do not have the decryption keys. A requirement of assured decryptability for all data would force such companies to redesign their products without security features like end-to-end encryption or to introduce deliberate vulnerabilities, or back doors, into their software.
The overwhelming consensus of information security experts, along with some former Five Eyes intelligence officials, is that there is no technical solution that would allow specific law enforcement agencies to decrypt communications without creating vulnerabilities that would expose all users to harm. Europol has also warned that solutions that intentionally weaken technical protection mechanisms to support law enforcement will intrinsically weaken the protection against criminals as well. Determined cybercriminals and rival foreign intelligence agencies will find and exploit such back doors, for profit or abuse. This would undermine cybersecurity for all users, including billions that are under no suspicion of wrongdoing.
For human rights defenders and journalists, the harm can be even more serious. Activists and media organizations with whom we work in places like Hong Kong, Vietnam, Thailand, and across the Middle East rely on encryption built into phones and chat applications to protect sources and victims from reprisals. In 2015, the UN special rapporteur on freedom of expression, David Kaye, recognized that encryption enables the exercise of freedom of expression, privacy, and a range of other rights in the digital age. Countries like Russia, China, and Turkey need no encouragement, they are already blurring the line between human rights activism and terrorism in order to justify surveillance and repression of human rights activists.
While strong encryption may limit some existing surveillance capabilities, weakening such security features will only increase the vulnerability of billions of ordinary people to cybercrime, identify theft, and malicious hacking. Such harm would be broadly disproportionate to any gains in law enforcement capabilities that undermining encryption would achieve.
It is also unlikely that limiting strong encryption in Australiaor even in all Five Eyes countries would prevent bad actors from using it. As a recent global survey of encryption products confirms, terrorists and criminals could easily shift to the many available foreign alternatives that would not be subject to Australian law.
Technology companies face an escalating digital arms race to secure their software and devices against cybercriminals, and encryption is a key part of their arsenal. Instead of hindering efforts to protect ordinary users, we urge your government to invest in modernizing investigation techniques and increasing resources and training in tools already at their disposal, consistent with human rights requirements. For example, any limitations encryption poses to police capabilities are greatly offset by the explosion of new kinds of investigatory material enabled by the digital world, including location information and vast stores of metadata that are not encrypted. And encrypted data can often be accessed in unencrypted form through cloud-based backups or by directly accessing it on devices with hacking or forensic tools. Of course, these alternative approaches should also be necessary and proportionate to legitimate security goals, regulated in public law, and subject to strict safeguards to ensure respect for privacy and other rights.
Australias approach to encryption will be emulated by other countries facing similar challenges. Your government can demonstrate true leadership by adapting to a world with strong encryption instead of fighting the gains the private sector has made in shoring up security and human rights in the digital age.
Elaine PearsonAustralia Director
Cynthia WongSenior Internet Researcher
Senator the Hon. George Brandis QC, Attorney-General
Mr. Michael Phelan APM, Acting Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police
 See, for example, Sam Thielman, “Yahoo hack: 1bn accounts compromised by biggest data breach in history,” The Guardian, December 15, 2016, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/14/yahoo-hack-security-o… (accessed August 2, 2017); Nicole Perlroth & David Sanger, “Hacks Raise Fear Over N.S.A.s Hold on Cyberweapons,” New York Times, June 28, 2017, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/28/technology/ransomware-nsa-hacking-too… (accessed August 2, 2017).
 Eliza Borrello, “Malcolm Turnbull confirms he uses Wickr, WhatsApp instead of unsecure SMS technology,” ABC News, March 2, 2015, http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-03-03/malcolm-turnbull-uses-secret-messa… (accessed August 2, 2017).
 Nicole Perlroth, “Security Experts Oppose Government Access to Encrypted Communication,” New York Times, July 7, 2015, https://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/08/technology/code-specialists-oppose-us… (accessed August 2, 2017); Mike McConnell, Michael Chertoff and William Lynn, Why the fear over ubiquitous data encryption is overblown, July 28, 2015, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-need-for-ubiquitous-data-enc… (accessed August 2, 2017); John Leyden, “Former GCHQ boss backs end-to-end encryption,” The Register, July 10, 2017, https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/07/10/former_gchq_wades_into_encrypti… (accessed August 2, 2017).
 Europol and ENISA joint statement, “On lawful criminal investigation that respects 21st Century data protection,” May 20, 2016, https://www.enisa.europa.eu/publications/enisa-position-papers-and-opini… (accessed August 2, 2017).
 UN Human Rights Council, Report of the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression, David Kaye, A/HRC/29/32, May 22, 2015, http://ap.ohchr.org/documents/dpage_e.aspx?si=A/HRC/29/32 (accessed August 2, 2017).
 B. Schneier, K. Seidel, and S. Vijayakumar, A Worldwide Survey of Encryption Products, February 11, 2016, https://www.schneier.com/academic/archives/2016/02/a_worldwide_survey_o…. (accessed August 2, 2017).
 Orin Kerr and Bruce Schneier, Encryption Workarounds, March 20, 2017, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2938033 (accessed August 2, 2017).
- What Is Encryption? | Surveillance Self-Defense - December 4th, 2017
- Comodo Disk Encryption Download - softpedia.com - December 1st, 2017
- Encryption - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - November 24th, 2017
- BitLocker Drive Encryption Overview - technet.microsoft.com - November 23rd, 2017
- The Encrypting File System - technet.microsoft.com - November 18th, 2017
- FBI cant break the encryption on Texas shooters smartphone - November 13th, 2017
- DOJ: Strong encryption that we dont have access to is ... - November 13th, 2017
- DOJ Fires Up New War With Apple Over Encryption - November 12th, 2017
- Security Awareness - Encryption | Office of Information ... - October 15th, 2017
- Data Encryption and Decryption (Windows) - October 14th, 2017
- Trumps DOJ tries to rebrand weakened encryption as responsible ... - October 11th, 2017
- How to encrypt (almost) anything | PCWorld - September 22nd, 2017
- Private Internet Access | VPN Encryption - September 21st, 2017
- Encryption Substitutes | Privacy | Encryption - September 21st, 2017
- Data Encryption: Hardware & Software Security: Online ... - September 21st, 2017
- How To Enable BitLocker Drive Encryption In Windows 10? - September 21st, 2017
- PGP Encryption Tool - iGolder - September 21st, 2017
- encryption - How to encrypt String in Java - Stack Overflow - September 21st, 2017
- Encryption Software Market, Size, Trends and Forecast 2020 - September 21st, 2017
- Encryption Definition - Tech Terms - September 20th, 2017
- Why You Should Be Encrypting Your Devices and How to Easily Do It - Gizmodo - September 6th, 2017
- Black Hats, White Hats, and Hard Hats The Need for Encryption in Mining and Resources - Australian Mining - September 6th, 2017
- How can enterprises secure encrypted traffic from cloud applications? - TechTarget - September 6th, 2017
- Encryption Explained - Arizona Daily Wildcat - September 6th, 2017
- News in brief: Call to link encryption to ID; Facebook maps everyone ... - Naked Security - September 2nd, 2017
- 'Independent' gov law reviewer wants users preemptively identified before they're 'allowed' to use encryption - The Register - September 2nd, 2017
- High-Dimensional Quantum Encryption Performed in Real-World ... - Futurism - September 2nd, 2017
- It's Time to Replace Your Encryption-Key Spreadsheet - Data Center Knowledge - September 2nd, 2017
- Legislation to limit smartphone encryption 'may be necessary,' deputy AG Rosenstein says - Washington Times - August 31st, 2017
- Cloud Encryption Market by Component, Service Model, Organization Size, Vertical And Region - Global Forecast to ... - Markets Insider - August 31st, 2017
- Cipher Suites: Ciphers, Algorithms and Negotiating Security Settings - Hashed Out by The SSL Store (registration) (blog) - August 31st, 2017
- Encryption in Office 365 - Office 365 - August 29th, 2017
- Need-to-Know Only: Use Encryption to Make Data Meaningless to ... - Security Intelligence (blog) - August 29th, 2017
- Four strategies to prevent data encryption from hijacking your network - Digital News Asia - August 29th, 2017
- Amber Rudd is wrong - real people do want end-to-end encryption - ITProPortal - August 29th, 2017
- Why encryption is for everyone - IFEX - August 29th, 2017
- 4D quantum encryption successful in first real-world test - New Atlas - New Atlas - August 29th, 2017
- For the First Time Ever, Quantum Communication is Demonstrated in Real-World City Conditions - Futurism - August 26th, 2017
- High-Dimensional Quantum Encryption Takes Place in Real-World ... - Photonics.com - August 26th, 2017
- Hedvig Bakes Encryption into Software-Defined Storage Platform - IT Business Edge (blog) - August 26th, 2017
- Hedvig storage upgrade adds flash tier, encryption options - TechTarget - August 26th, 2017
- How to use EFS encryption to encrypt individual files and folders on Windows 10 - Windows Central - August 26th, 2017
- Cloud Encryption Market Worth 2401.9 Million USD by 2022 - Markets Insider - August 23rd, 2017
- To Protect Genetic Privacy, Encrypt Your DNA - WIRED - August 23rd, 2017
- Data Encryption in OneDrive for Business and SharePoint Online - August 21st, 2017
- Researchers use encryption to keep patients' DNA private - Engadget - August 21st, 2017
- Additional proof that Lancaster County Commissioners should reconsider encrypting police transmissions - LancasterOnline - August 21st, 2017
- iPhone Secure Enclave firmware encryption key leaked - TechTarget - August 21st, 2017
- Encryption, speed push the modern mainframe into the future - TechTarget - August 21st, 2017
- Hardware encryption vs software encryption: the simple guide - Kroll Ontrack UK (press release) (blog) - August 21st, 2017
- Encryption Technology Could Protect the Privacy of Your DNA - Gizmodo - August 21st, 2017
- Beginner's guide to Windows 10 encryption - Windows Central - August 18th, 2017
- Encryption key for iPhone 5s Touch ID exposed, opens door to further research - AppleInsider (press release) (blog) - August 18th, 2017
- How security pros look at encryption backdoors - Help Net Security - August 18th, 2017
- The Laws of Mathematics and the Laws of Nations: The Encryption Debate Revisited - Lawfare (blog) - August 18th, 2017
- 72 percent of security pros say encryption backdoors won't stop terrorism - BetaNews - August 18th, 2017
- Ex-MI5 Boss Evans: Don't Undermine Encryption - Infosecurity Magazine - August 14th, 2017
- Despite end to end encryption, apps like WhatsApp, Messenger are still vulnerable to hacking: Study - Firstpost - August 13th, 2017
- What is Encryption? (with pictures) - wiseGEEK - August 12th, 2017
- Ex-MI5 chief warns against crackdown on encrypted messaging ... - The Guardian - August 12th, 2017
- Former UK security service head says weakening encryption would be too dangerous - 9to5Mac - August 12th, 2017
- News in brief: facial recognition planned for Carnival; spy chief backs encryption; ginger emoji planned - Naked Security - August 12th, 2017
- Avoid getting lost in encryption with these easy steps - We Live Security (blog) - August 12th, 2017
- Here's why IBM Z Mainframe Wants to Encrypt the World - Edgy Labs (blog) - August 10th, 2017
- Symantec Announces Plesk Will Integrate Symantec Encryption Everywhere Security Into Its Website Management ... - Business Wire (press release) - August 10th, 2017
- Australia: Shelve Proposed Law to Weaken Encryption - Human Rights Watch (press release) - August 6th, 2017
- IBM India Helps Create Breakthrough Encryption Technology That's Completely Hacker Proof - Indiatimes.com - August 6th, 2017
- Zscaler Finds Hackers Using SSL Encryption in Malware to Hide ... - eWeek - August 5th, 2017
- HBO Hack Highlights Importance of Encryption, Data Governance - eSecurity Planet - August 3rd, 2017
- UK flip-flop on encryption doesn't help anyone - CNET - August 3rd, 2017
- UpVote: Turkish regime jails IT trainers in encryption clampdown - Ars Technica UK - August 3rd, 2017
- Telegram messaging app strikes deal with Indonesia on encryption - Digital Trends - August 2nd, 2017
- Encryption is for 'Real People' - Human Rights Watch - August 2nd, 2017
- We don't want to ban encryption, but our inability to see what terrorists are plotting undermines our security - Telegraph.co.uk - August 2nd, 2017
- Real people don't need encryption - Fudzilla - August 2nd, 2017
- Ex-NSA boss questions encrypted message access laws proposed by Malcolm Turnbull - ABC Online - August 2nd, 2017
- Facebook's Sheryl Sandberg: WhatsApp metadata informs governments about terrorist activity in spite of encryption - CNBC - July 31st, 2017
- Commissioners need to rethink encryption - LancasterOnline - July 31st, 2017
- Ex-NSA chief Chris Inglis backs government's encryption push against Apple, Facebook - The Australian Financial Review - July 31st, 2017
- Oak Ridge licenses its quantum encryption method - FCW.com - July 31st, 2017